Menu
DINNER MENU – Fall 2026
– RAW BAR & CRUDO –
*Tartare Fresh Crudo, Soy, Lime, Pomegranate Ponzu, Edamame, Wakame Salad, Wontons MP *GF/DF
Oysters on the Half Shell Rotating Fresh Oysters, Shucked to Order, Mignonette & Cocktail 4 GF/DF
*Waterfront Oyster Shooter Absolut Pepper Vodka, House ‘Bloody Mary’ + Fresh Shucked Oyster 6 DF
Cocktail Verde Chilled Poached Shrimp, Green Gazpacho, Tomatillo, Citrus, Cucumber, Cilantro, Serrano 18 GF/DF
– SMALLER PLATES –
Jimmy’s Popcorn Locally Made Craft Popcorn, Caramel & Cheddar Mix 7 GF
Bread & Butter House Baked Ciabatta, Black Garlic & Thyme Compound Butter, Maldon Salt 6
Chopped Caesar Romaine, Garlic Confit, Sundried Tomato, Parmesan, Crouton Crumb, Anchovy 15 *GF
Wedge Bacon, Aged Balsamic, Sunflower Seed, Tomato, Chive, Radish, Creamy Ranch, Blue Crumble 15 GF
Seasonal Greens Snap Peas, Mint, Radish, Zucchini, Burrata, Walnut Dukkah, Lemon Vinaigrette 16 GF/*DF
Oysters Rockefeller (6) Blue Point Oysters, Spinach, Pancetta, Parmesan, Garlic, Lemon, Breadcrumb 26
Chicken Liver Paté Brown Butter, Blueberry Balsamic Compote, House Pickles, Crisps & Chips 18 *GF
Crispy Calamari Lightly Breaded Calamari, Pepperoncini, Green Beans, Lemon Garlic Aioli + Marinara 16
Smoked Salmon Dip Charlie’s Local Smoked Salmon, Herb Crème, Lemon, Tabasco, Crisps & Chips 16 *GF
Shrimp & Grits White Cheddar Creamy Grits, Creole Sauce, Cajun Blackened Shrimp, Giardiniera 20 *GF
*Lamb Frites Garlic & Herb Marinated Petite Lollipop Chops, Frites, Bistro Sauce 30 GF/DF
– LAND & SEA –
Green Goddess Pasta Herb Lemon Sauce, Tahini, Burrata Cheese, Chili Pepita Crunch 25 V/*DF
Bolognese Pappardelle Pasta, Classic Simmered Meat Sauce, Bechamel, Aged Parmesan, Cheese Tuille 26
Perch & Chips Tempura Battered Lake Perch, Traditional Cabbage Slaw, Hand Cut Fries, Tartar Sauce 30
Local Whitefish Panko Crust, Broccolini, Roasted Baby Potato, Toasted Almond, Lemon, Caper Butter 34
Salmon Seared Norwegian Salmon, Citrus Pearl Couscous Salad, Coconut Curry, Snow Peas 36 *GF/DF
Alaskan Halibut Pan Seared, Parmesan Risotto, Haricots Verts, Herb Oil, Citrus Beurre Blanc 42 GF
Cast Iron Chicken Deboned Half Chicken, White Cheddar Grits, Spinach, Charred Lemon, Mustard Seed 35 GF
*Grilled Tenderloin Heirloom Carrots, Whipped Yukon Golds, Black Garlic Thyme Butter, Demi, Crisp Carrot 46 GF/*DF
*Grilled Ribeye Heirloom Carrots, Whipped Yukon Golds, Black Garlic Thyme Butter, Demi, Crisp Carrot 16oz 62 GF/*DF
– COMPLEMENTS –
Pommes Frites Hand Cut Potatoes, Zataar, Parsley, Aioli 8 GF/DF
Broccolini Whipped Tahini, Ginger, Lemon, Pistachio Gremolata 8 GF/DF/V
Roastie Potatoes – Roasted Baby Potatoes, Herb Butter, Chives 8 GF
-SWEETS-
Carrot Cake, Mascarpone Cream Cheese Frosting, Salted Caramel 14
Flourless Valrhona Chocolate Cake, Whipped Cream, Berries 14 (GF)
Creme Brulee Vanilla Bean Custard, Torched Sugar, Chantilly Cream 14 (GF)
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness
GF = Gluten Free DF= Dairy Free V=Vegetarian *GF = Gluten Free With Adjustments
Hours & Contact
Open Tuesday - Saturday
Closing for the season on November 14, 2026.
Walk-ins always welcome!
For reservations, please book online.
Location & Directions
10947 N. Hwy 42
Sister Bay, WI 54234
One mile north of Downtown Sister Bay